A Gentleman Called Dorothy Salisbury Davis A Gentleman Called by Dorothy Salisbury Davis Sign in to put this book on your shelf. Prize history Edgar Award for Best Novel 1959 Nominee Edgar Award for Best Novel 1959 nominees The Eighth Circle Stanley Ellin The Eighth Circle Stanley Ellin Winner The Madhouse in Washington Square David Alexander The Madhouse in Washington Square David Alexander The Woman in the Woods Lee Blackstock The Woman in the Woods Lee Blackstock