A Sudden Flicker of Light

First published 2026 · debut

Reception

Mostly positive. 12 of 14 critics were positive or better.

Rave 5 · Positive 7 · Mixed 1 · Pan 1

  • “While the movies have declined, Thomson argues that so too has life ‘become a movie.’ We are so enclosed by screens that we struggle to think beyond them”

    Bookforum · Georgie Carr · Positive

2 more quotes
  • “A book-length renunciation of his career would be quite the ave, but Thomson can’t commit to that. He pleads his case like a brilliant drunk representing himself at night court”

    Harpers · Dan Piepenbring · Mixed

  • “I can’t recall such a bleak appraisal of an art form since Tipper Gore went after Twisted Sister in the 1980s”

    The Atlantic · Michael O'Donnell · Pan

All 14 reviews on Book Marks

  1. 2026
    The Atlantic

    Reviewed by Michael O'Donnell, 1 July

  2. 2026
    The Guardian

    Reviewed, 20 July

Read the 2 reviews
  • The Guardian · 20 July 2026

    A Sudden Flicker of Light by David Thomson review – a brilliantly eccentric history of the movies

    Read at The Guardian (opens in a new tab)

  • The Atlantic · 1 July 2026 · Pan

    A Sudden Flicker of Light

    “I can’t recall such a bleak appraisal of an art form since Tipper Gore went after Twisted Sister in the 1980s ... Thomson’s book, coming late in his career, is more successful as a provocation than as a persuasive indictment of cinema ... Thomson sprinkles critique throughout his book like seasoning unevenly applied to a gamey piece of meat. He concedes that his argument jumps around confusingly, ”

    By Michael O'Donnell

    Read at The Atlantic (opens in a new tab)